Race Chief Trevor Phillips has received an overwhelming vote of no confidence in an opinion poll of prospective leaders for the new single equalities body.
A paltry four per cent of people who responded to the poll that was conducted on Blink, the website of the 1990 Trust, believe the Commission for Racial Equality chair would be an effective leader in driving forward race equality agendas.
Phillips, (pictured), who is being considered for the role, finished last in a list of credible contenders for the position – trailing behind other contenders, including former CRE chair Lord Herman Ouseley.
The CEHR will bring together the work of the Disability Rights Commission, Equal Opportunities Commission and the CRE from 2009.
Campaign groups, such as Operation Black Vote and 1990 Trust say the appointment of Phillips to the new body would ‘hammer the final nail in the coffin’ for the new body.
Although mainstream Britain has by and large lauded his three-year tenure as CRE chief, Phillips has come in for a bit of a hard time of it of late with community activists who say he has followed the government’s agenda too closely rather than challenge its policies on race.
They slammed him last October when he called for a new ‘highway code’ of rules to be reached by questioning basic assumptions such as the use of the word coloured, the desirability of official documents being printed in several languages and the universal recognition of minority religious holidays. In response to their poll, the 1990 Trust Board of Trustees issued a statement that said: ‘We have seen a never-ending stream of headline-grabbing comments from [Phillips] that do not focus on the issues that matter and actually do damage to the interests of people who look to the CRE to protect them from race discrimination.
‘The poll, while not scientific by any means, does reflect what we’ve heard from black communities across Britain.’
Other campaign groups were quick to back up the 1990 Trust and said they believe Phillips’s Equalities Review of government policies focusing on integration represents a further ‘missed opportunity’.
Simon Woolley, national coordinator of Operation Black Vote who were also involved in the poll, said: ‘It’s a shame because at times he can be very good.
He added: ‘It’s not personal but race equality is so important that we need somebody that is going to effectively challenge the institution.’
More than 300 votes were polled, with Liberty director Shami Chakrabarti receiving 43 per cent, Lord Ouseley 36 per cent and ex-trades union leader Sir Bill Morris 17 per cent.
The CRE said: ‘Trevor Phillips will not be making a response to the 1990 Trust/ OBV statement or the poll and as it is not really a CRE matter we cannot really pass comment.’